The Ugly Volvo

An Open Letter to the Female Hat-Wearing Dog From “Go Dog, Go”

Dear female hat-wearing dog,

I bought your book to help my son learn prepositions and adjectives and was, from the first read, inexorably drawn in by your heart-wrenching struggle for approval.ย  Momentarily distracted by the humdrum parade of big dogs, little dogs, black and white dogs, I watched as you walked in, brimming with joy and confidence, and looked on as some total nobody, indistinguishable from most of the other dogs in this book, crushed you with his subtle rejection.

do you like my hat 1 full theuglyvolvo
“Do you like my hat?” “I do not.”

And you donโ€™t even know me, but I wanted to take a minute to tell you that what matters is thatย youย likeย your ownย hat, hat-wearing female dog.ย  Who is this guy anyway, some sort of dog hat expert??ย  Who cares what he thinks???ย  Wear a hat you love and if he doesnโ€™t like it?ย ย F*#% him.

I want you toย take this in, hat-wearing female dog, lest you spend the next 15 years of your life trying to impress someone who is not worth your time.ย ย Ignore the hat-based norms of the dog universeย and wearย what makes YOU happy. ย Celebrate yourself! ย You are awesome and unique, like that dancing eleven-year-old in the blonde wig from Siaโ€™s Chandelierย video, only a dog version!

So you try again.

feather steal theuglyvolvo
Just because someone owns a bowler hat doesn’t make them the Tim Gunn/Bill Cunningham of the dog fashion universe.

Andย not only does he shut you down once again (โ€œDo you like my hat?โ€ โ€œI do not like it.โ€)ย he literally steals the feather out of your hat as he rides off on his scooter. ย OMG, WHAT IS HIS ISSUE, RIGHT? ย SCREW HIM AND HIS DUMB SCOOTER AND HIS HALFHEARTED FOUR-DAY-LATER FOLLOW UP TEXT MESSAGES.ย ย (Not into UR hat, babe.ย  U look cute tho.)

If youโ€™re seeking approval because youโ€™re itching to be in a relationship right now, know that there are other fish in the sea and, more importantly,ย bazillions of other dogs in this book.ย  Without even looking I found some big dogs and some little dogs going around in cars.ย  I found a red dog on a blue tree.ย  I found a green dog on a yellow tree.ย  I found two dogs in a house on a boat in the water and three dogs at a party on a boat at night.ย  All of whom seem single, ready to mingle, and possibly capable of empathy. ย The female-to-male dog ratio in this book is totally in your favor so why are you selling yourself short???

dog party theuglyvolvo
Admittedly this is like the world’s most pathetic party, but in fairness they seem like nice guys.

Forget this dude who isn’t into your hats!ย  It shouldnโ€™t be hardโ€”he is so completely and totally forgettable because P.D. Eastman draws all dogs more or less identically.ย  And yet like so many cartoon female dogs, you only have eyes for some generic nobody who canโ€™t see how freaking fantastic you are.ย  You confront thisย guyย a third time, desperately searching for the hat validation that since childhood youโ€™ve been told you need.

ski hat confrontation
“I’m just a boy, standing in front of a girl, telling her I don’t like her hat.”

IT IS NOTย ABOUT THE HATโ€”ARE YOU LISTENING???ย  It doesn’t matter if he likes your hat or not. ย I wantย youย to feel the burning radiation of your self-worth as you say, โ€œTHIS IS ME.ย  THIS IS WHO I AM.ย  IF YOUโ€™RE NOT INTO ME BECAUSE Iโ€™M WEARING AN UNCOMFORTABLY LONG SKI HAT, MAYBE THIS IS NOT THE RIGHT RELATIONSHIP FOR EITHER OF US.โ€

But you’re not ready to do that. ย And like so many relationships, it comes to a head at a party.ย  A dog party.ย  A big dog party.

dog party tree
Unlike that other ‘party’ that consisted of three dogs, a checkerboard, a banjo and a lollipop, this one is actually like a legit party.

Big dogs, little dogs, red dogs, blue dogs, are all at a dog party. ย What a dog party! ย Andย you show up looking totally cute and you approach him again (In fairness, I admire your tenacity) and ask one final time if he likes your latest hat.ย  A hat topped with a flower pot and a pennant flag–one that has no fewer than two spiders and a goldfish dangling off it. ย A hat that features a bouquet of lollipops and three candy canes in close proximity to a mop that clearly you only put on because you lost a bet.

close up on crazy hat
This hat is Vera Wang’s living nightmare.

So you ask if he likes your hat and he’s like “Yes! ย I like it! ย I like that party hat!” and you guys drive off together into the sunset. ย And it seems like an idyllic future, except that there is literally no way you can wear this hat every day without sustaining major neck damage. ย So you guys settle down, date for a few months, maybe move in together, but eventually you get to the point where you’re like “I sort of don’t want to wear this hat every day just to keep this relationship going.” ย And honestly, at this point he’s not even into the hat anymore because the novelty is wearing off. ย The sex isn’t as good. ย You lie awake in bed next to each other staring at your phones as you frantically wonder if you should buy a new hat to spice things up. Have you gone right back to being invisible? ย Who are you to him now?ย  Just a series of crazy Mardi Gras-style hats?

goodbye

Assess your value,ย female hat-wearing dog. ย Take a minute to really look at yourself in the mirror and say:

ย “I am a moderately well-drawn ketchup-colored poodle and my storyline is the closest thing this book has to a plot. ย I am the only thing pulling the narrative along. ย I’m well-groomed, enjoy skiing, and have enough disposable income to amass a comfortable hat wardrobe.”

And then feel free to ask your reflection if it likes your hat. ย And if your reflection isย like, “Girrrrrrl, you look amazing regardless of whether or not you’re even wearing a hat,” maybe ditch this mustard-colored moronย who immediately ends a date when he’s notย diggingย the girl’s hat because youโ€™re terrific and life is short and sh*tย like that’s not worth your time. ย ย 

Good-bye!

Good-bye!

ย  ย * ย  ย  ย  ย  * ย  ย  ย  ย  ย *

Welcome to the Club: 100 Parenting Milestones You Never Saw Coming

ย If you are attending a baby shower in the near future, I have a bookย out designed as a gift for new parents calledย Welcome to the Club: 100 Parenting Milestones You Never Saw Comingย that you can purchase through Amazon,ย Barnes and Nobleย or Indiebound. ย It is a very small, lightweight book that can be read by someone who is averaging 3-4 hours sleep a night that reminds themย that eventually, someday, they will maybe get 5 orย (perhaps I am being ambitious) 6 full hours of sleep again. ย Someday. ย Maybe.

If you enjoyed thisย piece, please share it and/or follow The Ugly Volvoย onย Facebook or Twitter.

I know at least one person will be upset that I “canโ€™t just enjoy the book Go Dog Go like everybody else” so if anyone needs me Iโ€™ll be right here repeatedly banging my head into the wall and writing the word โ€œSatireโ€ on my tile floor with Crayola bath crayons.

Also, if you’d like to buy the book Go, Dog, Go, do that too! ย Despite my making fun of it, it’s a lovely book that I have read about 4,000 times. ย It’s literally like 5 bucks. ย My book is like 12 bucks. ย Go nuts.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Comments

253 responses to “An Open Letter to the Female Hat-Wearing Dog From “Go Dog, Go””

  1. Linda Hazzard Avatar
    Linda Hazzard

    Oh, it was so nice to start my day reading something funny and lighthearted. Close to genius in your observations I must say.

  2. I think that the fact that the author spells goodbye without the e bothers me more.

    1. Raquel D'Apice Avatar
      Raquel D’Apice

      YES,THIS.

  3. Kristen Avatar
    Kristen

    Also, during that last encounter it looks like the male mustard colored dog is already slightly drunk before he even got to the party. Not a good sign.

    I always try to imbue the female dog’s “Goodbye”s with a tone that implies the addition of “Asshole.”

  4. Possibly due to the fact that I’ve read that book 183,000 times as well, I always wondered why that jerk never liked the cool hats but loved the one she clearly put together just to get a reaction. Also, as a SAHM with way too much time on my hands, I have theories about Blue’s Clues and Bob the Builder if anyone is interested.

    1. There should be a *like* button

  5. Why are you assuming it’s a female dog?

  6. Pam Picray Avatar
    Pam Picray

    Thank you making me truly laugh aloud! I am a school librarian and often have similar thoughts when reading certain books to my students. Will not be able to read this one aloud in the near future as I’ll be remembering what you said!

  7. A'Llyn Ettien Avatar
    A’Llyn Ettien

    TRUTH. That yellow dog is a giant jerk. Move on and take your awesome hats with you, little red dog.

  8. Carrie Avatar
    Carrie

    This made me smile. Wear that hat, female hat-wearing dog!
    But wait…
    Do we even know that the hat-wearing dog is female? Being a poodle does not automatically mean one is necessarily a female poodle. Come to that, do we even know the gender of the other, non-hat-wearing dogs in this book? All we can say for certain is that a dog’s choice of headwear should be solely based on that dog’s own wishes on the topic, and hat shaming is never right.
    WEAR THAT HAT, hat-wearing dog of indeterminate gender!

  9. I so needed this today! And I have had some of these exact thoughts regarding this poor dog…thank you!!

  10. Well, THIS sure brings me back to one of my all-time fave books as a kid…and how MAD I’d get at that stupid dog for insulting her hat AND stealing her feather. I felt so bad for the hat-wearing dog! Thanks for vindicating her after all these years and turning my inarticulate tot-rage into a coherent narrative ๐Ÿ™‚

  11. I never considered the hat-wearing dog to be a female. I always just looked at him as a rather flamboyant dresser!

  12. You are hilarious — and not just because I have a 4-year-old and drive an ugly Volvo. Thank you for writing! I read Go Dog Go (and read it, and read it) totally differently: I love that she doesn’t give two shits whether he likes her hat or not! Good by! She is not fazed. She wears whatever hat she wants. Talk to the paw! Canine Miranda!

  13. I laughed out loud at this post (and shared on FB, obviously). The first time I read this to my daughter I *had* to stop and ensure that she knew that the boy dog was really an a**hole and THEN when she (the girl dog) went off into the distance with him at the end I sort of rounded on my daughter (she was 4) and told her that “Anyone who can’t be kind to you no matter what kind of hat you are wearing is NO FRIEND! You should not try to earn their approval and you certainly shouldn’t go off with them in a car! The whole thing reeks of emotional abuse.” She (my daughter) still, two years later, hollers in indignation “He is NOT NICE” when we read this story to her younger brother. Mission accomplished.

  14. I didn’t think it was a girl dog, I thought they were both boy dogs continually trying to one up each other in hat-dom. All boy dog fashion is cutting edge! Yellow dog is still mean though

  15. Cassidy Stockton Avatar
    Cassidy Stockton

    Finally. Finally someone else thinks this whole hat business is weird. Thank you for being a dog feminist… is that a thing? This gave me such a good chuckle that it will now be impossible to read this book without thinking “you go girl, screw that dog, you and your hats don’t need him”

  16. I think you should send this post to P.D. Eastman, post it as a review of this stupid book (by the way, I don’t see any prepositions or adjectives in what you’ve shown us, though I acknowledge I’ve never seen this book before and maybe there are some fabulous adjectives hidden away elsewhere), and STOP READING IT TO YOUR SON! Or at least read it to him with your own completely reasonable commentary.

  17. I have also read this book 4000 times. I never knew quite how to read those pages. They have baffled me for years. “Why would that be in a children’s book? I must not be getting the point.” Good to know I’m not missing something. Agreed, there are plenty of other dogs worth dating in this book. Like the one chilling with lemonade in the shade.

  18. That was great! I confess that although I have had “Go Dog Go” read to me and I have read “Go Dog Go” to my children, I had not considered the issues with hat acceptance. Well done!

    However I am proud that I have gotten people at parties to move away from me while I explain how “The Little Engine That Could” is about how adults don’t take children’s problems seriously.

  19. Wow! I had always thought this same thing every time I read this book but thought I was just crazy. Now I know. I am crazy but so is at least one other person. I absolutely love your blog.

    1. Raquel D'Apice Avatar
      Raquel D’Apice

      thanks!

  20. Melissa Avatar
    Melissa

    Thanks. This made me lol. Literally. Right out loud like a crazy person.

  21. Melanie Avatar
    Melanie

    Found this article on a friend’s Facebook! I had always assumed both dogs were male. The red dog doesn’t have any of the stereotypical illustrated female animal features (this illustrator gives big eyes to everyone). No bows, no long lashes, no wheedling expressions. So I just assumed a boy poodle trying to impress a big brother figure, perhaps. Can’t poodles be boys? ๐Ÿ˜‰ Yellow dog is still no friend at all, granted, but I didn’t see the gender implications there at ALL.

  22. In heartfelt support of dear Female Hat-Wearing Dog-

    Forget that guy, he is a jerk,
    An asshole, a real piece of work.
    Like she said, there are pages full
    Of better guys. Iโ€™m sure that youโ€™ll
    Be happier with some dog who
    Plays checkers on the ocean blue,
    Ok, I forced that rhyme a bit,
    But honestly, that guyโ€™s a shit.

  23. peggy langford Avatar
    peggy langford

    I love the way that you think!!!

  24. There’s actually nothing in the text that genders either dog.

  25. David Schallert Avatar
    David Schallert

    …wait, so she asks his opinion of her hat, he gives it, then they part on friendly terms.

    Giving an honest opinion is not cruelty, and the “female dog” as you label the dog that happens to be a red poodle (while none of them are this color naturally, I can assure you there are roughly 50% male poodles, and I am sure many of them are forced to wear stupid hats) very well may have the very attitude you so want them to have. At no time does it cry or lament the fact the mustard dog doesn’t like the hats, it just moves on.

    Stealing the feather was a dick move though.

  26. Dude… that was some of the funniest $#*+ I’ve ever read.

  27. Oh so funny. I admit I always kind of thought the dude dog was kind of a douche, but admired the poodle’s spunk. She never seems particularly put down when her hat is disliked, her chin is always up as she sashays off, no matter what douche dog says.

  28. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve read this book to my daughter and thought the same thing. Thank you for writing about it so hilariously. I feel that I might read this post to my daughter (turning 2 on June 22) instead. P.S. Your dog is adorable! ๐Ÿ™‚

  29. This is really funny, and I appreciate the feminist reading, especially given how few main characters in kids’ media are non-princess females.
    And now I have to be “that” person, who repeats what a few others have said. Especially in the wake of Orlando, wouldn’t it be even more amazing for the haberdashery-loving pooch to be a gender non-conforming male, simply trying to broaden everyone’s appreciation of haberdashery? Because there are even fewer gender non-conforming main characters. Just a thought.

  30. That was the most poignant and entertaining bit of writing I’ve read on this waste-of-time internet all year. Keep it up, and love the hat.

  31. Even as a 4 year old, I knew that poodle was female.

  32. Thanks for your interesting article! Here are some counterpoints you may feel free to dismiss:

    She asked if he likes her hat and he said no. No unsolicited personal attacks were given; only an opinion that was literally asked for.

    It would be interesting to see a rebuttal in defense of the yellow dog. In today’s world, it is especially important to defend the right to voice our opinions and to remain open to ideas we may find uncomfortable.
    I worry the day may soon arrive when the desire to feel good about ourselves will outweigh our human right to freedom of speech.

    I think it is easy to look within ourselves and project onto the red dog insecurities that aren’t demonstrated in the book. The red dog simply accepts the opinion and moves on. The concept, “I am amazing in my own right, so who cares what others think?” ironically does not often occur to those with that kind of confidence. Usually it is those who consciously recite that mantra that are the most insecure in that regard. I don’t mean that as an insult in any way. We all have our insecurities ๐Ÿ™‚

    I guess my issue with it all is that if the red dog truly had the self confidence espoused in the article, then she wouldn’t do a single thing suggested in said article, but simply accept the other dog’s opinion as such and move on. (Which is exactly what she does in the book)

    Anyway, a good read!

    Respect.

    1. Raquel D'Apice Avatar
      Raquel D’Apice

      No worries– was a piece written in fun, but yours are also good points, well-presented. Thanks! I’d tip my hat to you but I need to stop dragging hats into all my interactions with other people.

  33. Barbara Avatar
    Barbara

    I LOVE this!! Hilarious, poignant and absolutely true. My kids and I have read that book so many times and so I read your article to them as well. We were all laughing so hard I was crying. And yet, as I said, the deeper points you are making are really spot on as well. Thank you!

  34. I always assumed she was in a hat making class, and he was the instructor. Makes the line of questioning totally reasonable. Tension builds as she is not able to please him (he: a world renowned hat maker with very specific tastes, she: a promising young protรฉgรฉ who he knows will respond to this tough love approach with an inevitable masterpiece that his tutelage inspired) and so by the end, when she shows him the party hat, they find the tension and tenacity (and party beverages) have led to a deep and abiding love, hence the ride off into the sunset.

    1. Raquel D'Apice Avatar
      Raquel D’Apice

      this is also a pretty great interpretation and sort of makes me want to take a hat making class??

  35. Wow. Interesting interpretation of the story. I have also read this book many times to my kids. I haver never thought of it than much more of a rhyming book. Pictures nice and bold, colourful. Clear text. Easy for beginner readers to associate words with the pictures. Until reading this article have i not once noticed one dog taking the feather from the hat. Does one think perhaps people read too much into things? Interesting read. I will ask my kids what they think. See what they come up with. Thanks for sharing

  36. Sarah B Avatar
    Sarah B

    Seen now through your lens, it occurs to me that it would be great if the ketchup-coloured poodle could hit the road with Jennie the Terrier of “Higglety Pigglety Pop!: Or There Must Be More to Life” fame.
    Jennie has ‘Two pillows, two bowls, a red wool sweater, eye drops, ear drops, two different bottles of pills, a thermometer” and could undoubtedly rock the hell out of a hat.

  37. Hilarious interpretation! As a kid I always puzzled over the sub text of those two dogs relationship. As a mom, I made feeble attempt to help my sons figure it out. I think you should write your own early reader with the Ketchup colored poodle as the main character!

  38. Always loved this book, and PD Eastman. And now for yet another interpretation of female hat-wearing dog (FHWD): I think she’s messing with him. Has anyone else noticed that the hats get more outlandish as the book goes on? “Do you like my hat?” “No.” “How about this one?” “No.” “This one, that will obviously cause me to wipe out while skiing?” “Nope.” “Okay, how about this ridiculous, neck-breaking monstrosity.” “YES!” “That’s what I thought. Have you noticed it’s completely ludicrous? No? I no longer value your opinion. Good-bye.” “Good-bye.”

  39. Tamara Avatar
    Tamara

    Absolutely hilarious and spot on. THANK YOU for the hearty laugh this morning. I must’ve read that book to my kids a bazillion times when they were little, and I didn’t like the idea that she kept on changing her hat until he approved. Bravo for you and your clever & funny letter. I have shared on my facebook feed and my Red Tent facebook page. I saw it when Lucy Pearce posted it. Keep writing! Marvelous!!!

  40. Tiltmom Avatar
    Tiltmom

    She’d get much better feedback from the foppish dog in _Old Hat New Hat_.

    He was rather specific about the flaws of each hat he tried on, and very much on point in his criticisms.

  41. CLAIRE ALEXANDER Avatar
    CLAIRE ALEXANDER

    Love this.

  42. This whole article is completely asinine. I mean, it’s fairly obvious that this female hat-wearing dog is not particularly the strongest willed female hat wearing dog of all time. Maybe she had a rough childhood that resulted in her lack of being able to make cogent decisions for herself as a adult hat-wearing dog. She appears vulnerable, disenfranchised, depressed, and perhaps even just simply downright weak-minded, searching for answers in this topsy-turvy hat-wearing world. It’s almost as if she has no real concept of who she is or what she’s all about, evident in her constant clamoring for approval from the other dogs who really just don’t appreciate her sense of “self” that she exudes forth when she dons “the hat”. It’s clear that this female hat-wearing dog needs feminism. Does feminism apply to dogs? If not, it should. Dogfemism. We will call it Dogfemism, yes, that works. Also, how do you know that this dog identifies as a she, eh? Just because the dog is pink(maybe magenta) and is a poodle, doesn’t mean that it is a “she”. Stop pigeonholing the gender and color-politics of hat-wearing dogs into absolutes, already(this dog has a dick, this dog has a vagina, stop it). “She” could be a skoliosexual genderfluid panromantic dogkin for all you know. Yeah, I bet you feel bad for calling the magenta poodle a “she”, you racist, transphobic piece of shit.

  43. Michele Avatar
    Michele

    Love this so much! I have often thought the same thing about that poor lady dog and you expressed this so perfectly. Thanks for the laugh!

  44. But she never seems crushed by the other dog’s comments, she just walks away with her sense of self-possession intact. I’ve always read the book the other way, as a test of the other dog rather than a quest for validation: “This is me. These are the hats I’m wearing at the time you see me. If you don’t like them, fine, but then you don’t get to hang out with me.”

  45. Matthew Avatar
    Matthew

    I always thought he rejected her hats because they were safe, middle-of-the-road choices and he knew she had so much more to offer. When she finally let her true self emerge in the form of a no-holds-barred party hat, then they both knew she was ready for a real relationship.

  46. Angela Avatar
    Angela

    I never noticed that jerky boy dog stole her feather!

  47. Yes! And you are not the only one out there who does this. I have serious issues with the co-dependency of The Giving Tree, my husband *hates* The Rainbow Fish (really? he must give them his very flesh before they will forgive him for being a little stuck up??) and another friend takes issue with the story of Tootle the train, who likes to go off the rails and frolick in the meadow but it forced back into a life of conformity.

  48. Yes! And you are not the only one who does this. I take issue with the unhealthy co-dependency of The Giving Tree, my husband hates that the Rainbow Fish must give his friends bits of his very flesh before they will forgive him for being a little stuck up, and another friend has a real problem with Tootle the train, who enjoys going off the rails to play in the meadow but is forced back into a life of conformity. And have you ever read the original Thomas the Tank Engine stories?? Everyone must know their place…UGH.

  49. Bobby-Bill Avatar
    Bobby-Bill

    That book is terrible because it perpetuates the “Nice Girl (TM)” idea that male dogs are vending machines, and if you insert enough hats a relationship will fall out. The way she keeps on approaching the same dog who’s clearly not interested is entitled and basically stalking, and the fact that the story makes him cave in at the end is only teaching children all the wrong things.

    Ladies, don’t be like that stalker dog. Don’t turn into a rapist.

  50. Ann Brzezinski Avatar
    Ann Brzezinski

    I have always loved the book Go Dog Go — as a child and as a parent who read it many times to my four kids. But, I also LOVE your satirical spin on the female hat-wearing dog! Great job — I’ll be sharing this with not only my two daughters, but also my two sons. Thank you for an enjoyable read.

  51. Crystal Avatar
    Crystal

    Awesome!

  52. Grace Decker Avatar
    Grace Decker

    I have read that book twenty five million times and it NEVER occurred to me that the poodle is a girl.
    I mean, it honestly never occurred to me.

  53. MaleCannotWin-InstantFailMale Avatar
    MaleCannotWin-InstantFailMale

    1) The dog is straight up honest about his opinion. Should he lie to her to protect her feelings? Of course not. Credit given for honesty: zero

    2) The male dog is polite and smiles at her before and after each exchange. Credit given for congenial behavior: zero

    3) In the second panel, he’s adopted a hat and cane. You don’t see him worry about if she likes the hat. He’s just playing along and enjoying the idea of a who-has-the-strangest-hat game. Credit given for playing along: zero

    4) Now the dog makes a bold move and playfully steals the feather from her hat: If the woman was offended, he might have apologized and moved on. But he correctly guesses that the woman will not be offended as she immediately comes back with yet another hat! Ah Ha! The male dog now suspects that there is some game afoot, because she just keeps coming at him with new and odd ball hats! He is intrigued, but cautious. Credit given for gently probing the boundaries of a new friendship while trying to balance playing along versus being stand offish: zero.

    5) Male dog is in the middle of effing no where, and boom out of the blue comes the crazy woman with the crazy hats again! Male dog is wary that the woman is just trying to find a meal ticket to feed her hat obsession, but he’s also bemused. He continues to be completely honest with her, tries to be polite and goes on about his day. Credit given for continued honesty: zero

    6) Male dog throws a giant party handing out cake for all of his friends. Hopefully female dog is actually interested in him and not just the fact that he has the funds to hand out cake and throw a big party, but he isn’t so cynical as to assume that from the get-go. Credit given for having a large group of friends which probably shows he’s not some giant jerk: zero

    7) Female dog flirts with him for the fourth time with an absolutely over the top hat. Male dog, busts up laughing. He realizes that he is really enjoying the game of who-has-the-craziest hat. He realizes that he has grown to have real affection for this female that clearly wants to spend time with him. He realizes that he has developed an appreciation for wild hats thanks to her. He says, โ€œYes! I like it! I like that party hat!โ€ but really, it’s not that the hat somehow makes her look good. It’s that by getting to know her, he suddenly realized that she is the one making the hat look good! He realizes that his affection for her has grown from casually polite honesty, through a continuing game into friendship, and suddenly into an honest desire to spend time with this woman.

    And so in the end, he invites her to ride off into the sunset with him. Clearly, the female dog in the book knew what she was doing the whole time, and the male dog acted honorably, honestly and respectfully as he grew to know her.

    The female dog in the book had confidence the whole time. She had the confidence and self-worth not to fall to pieces over a hat, but to decide what she wanted and to be willing to play and flirt and get to know the male dog and over time let him get to know her. In the end, they both had the honesty and self-worth to let things grow until they both found that what they were looking for was there the whole time.

    The hat was merely a harmless flirtatious game all along. It was his honesty that won her over. It was her playfulness that won him over.
    And they lived happily ever after.

    1. PD Westman Avatar
      PD Westman

      It’s rather like the Little Prince learning to tame the fox. It is a social game, but the rules are essential and stand the test of time.

  54. Rebecca Avatar
    Rebecca

    Why do you assume the poodle is female. ALL French poodles are trimmed that way. Also why is the yellow dog a male? These could be two female dogs having a conversation. You brought your pre conceived notions. The poodle with the fancy trim was a girl and the hound was the boy. The bottom line is boy dogs have “boy parts” on their belly. There are no parts shown therefore these are two female dogs.

  55. Georgene Avatar
    Georgene

    Back in the day when I was reading this book 4000 times, I often thought about the female hat wearing dog and her relentless need for validation. Thank you for bringing back the good old days of snuggling and reading with my formerly little guys.

  56. Two Replies Avatar
    Two Replies

    I find it pretty pathetic that someone would read so much into, and imply social subtext of A CHILDREN’S BOOK ABOUT (anthropomorphic) CARTOON DOGS.

  57. I’ve always felt there was something going on with that lady dog and her hat, something vaguely disturbing and … Icky. Thanks for the clarity!

  58. Kristi Robison Avatar
    Kristi Robison

    I just about died laughing at this, much as I too love Go, Dog, Go (so did my son). I am now EAGER to buy your book about parenting milestones, as I somehow fathom it will also be hilarious. Plus as a fellow parent-warrior, I suspect I’ll be able to relate. I have this urge to buy a hat like Ketchup Dog’s hat now, too….thanks!

  59. As a child, I always assumed the stranded object in her hat was an old-school pom, like the kind cheerleaders use, because it goes with the pennant.

    Interpreting it as a mop is stupendously funny, though.

    1. Raquel D'Apice Avatar
      Raquel D’Apice

      ok, I’m going to give you that the pom thing makes a lot of sense. whoops.

  60. Papa C Avatar
    Papa C

    That guy was negging. I will warn my daughter about him the next time I read the book to her. However, she’s 8 months old and probably just wants to eat the corner of the book at this point.

    1. My mother used to say of my brother “I buys him books, I buys him books and all he does is eat the covers.” To be fair that wasn’t all he ate. Slow moving bugs were a popular snack as well.

  61. I didn’t totally agree with your analysis. I think when the pink poodle says “Goodbye” she just doesn’t want to hang with someone who doesn’t recognize a good hat. She is not sad or heartbroken. Its when HE learns and HE changes to appreciate a good party hat that they hook up. She doesn’t keep seeking him out–they just keep running into each other because they run in the same dog circle of friends. Besides what other options does she really have? Would you hang with 2 big pink dogs going up? Or one little dog going down? GET OFF THE FERRIS WHEEL!!! Come on!! They are all hunting dogs and poodles anyway. No pit bulls or boxers or even a basset hound.

    Also–gotta appreciate a kids book (I grew up with it) that is all about 2 dogs getting together.

  62. “I just finished reading the heartwarming book ‘Go, Dog, Go.’ If I may read a passage: ‘Big dog. Little dog. A…red dog on a….’ Well, anyway, I don’t want to give away the ending, but I will say it spirals toward an incredible twist-turn that parallels my own life.”

    -Officer Barbrady, South Park

  63. I actually had the same impression when I read the book, but then I saw a children’s theater in Seattle perform Go Dog, Go, and it offered a totally new perspective. In that telling the male dog was just so painfully shy, that every time the female dog with the cute hat asked him a direct question he just had no idea how to respond and said something stupid. He finally works himself up, by the end of the play, to say what he wanted to say all along “I like that party hat” and then normal conversation takes over. At least it’s a positive spin on an otherwise creepy story line

  64. So glad to hear I’m not the only one who didn’t like the hat story line. I actually taped together the hat pages and never read them to my boys. That was 13 years ago. I’ve never censored another book, but I just couldn’t bear the thought of reading the hat saga every one of the hundreds of times we read that book together. She is so much more than a hat! I didn’t want my kids to think it was okay to just blurt out, “I do not like your hat” to a friend.

  65. I read this book over and over and over and over to my kids when they were little. On the dog party page, I’d have them point to a big dog, point to a red dog, etc. So much fun, and your post just CRACKED ME UP! Thanks for the humor on this story that is a part of my mommy memories. <3

  66. Yes but also the book CONSISTENTLY SPELLS GOODBYE WRONG. “Good-by”? Douche-bag canine love interests AND bad spelling is a terrible combination.

  67. My interpretation is slightly different. As mentioned, she is a successful dog with an impressive hat budget. I think the boy dog, despite seeming nondescript to Raquel, was notably attractive to the hat wearer. So she set out to win him, and succeeded soon enough. And then, having accomplished her goal, the next day, she forgot him and moved onto the next interesting dog.

  68. MikeMoran Avatar
    MikeMoran

    I just lived in a Latin American city for a year, and it was like a dog party. Dogs everywhere. Dogs on street corners, dogs crossing with the light, dogs playing with each other in parks. The trees were cool too, though I never saw any dogs having a party in any trees.

  69. Sheryl Avatar
    Sheryl

    Thank you! I’ve read this book to all three of my kids because in can’t bring myself to get rid of it. This part of the book has always bothered me!! Why does he have to approve of her hat? Why does she feel so codependent on him liking it? Why does she need his approval to be happy with her hat choices? If I was a conspiracy theorist Id be suspicious; and since I’m not-I’m just so bugged. Glad to know other people recognized the stupidity of these two characters’ dialogue and the codependency and insecurity it fosters

  70. Thank you for writing this, it delighted me and I wish *I* had written it! I’m so happy it exists, thanks for making it so!

  71. This is one of my favorite books from childhood. And childhood for me was a long time ago. But I return to “Go, Dog, Go!” often, and give it as a gift to new parents to help build their kids’ libraries.

    And in all this time, I never, ever thought about that dog as female or male. It’s a poodle, for goodness’ sakeโ€”of course it’s going to have a fabulous hat! If you returned to your piece and took “female” out of it (and therefore a couple of other things, like the “Girrrrrrl…” toward the end), I’d be completely right there with you. And you’d have made a statement that goes beyond girls, and is a message that many others need to take in as wellโ€”boys, LGBTQ folks…

    Respectfully,
    A longtime GDG! fan

  72. Maggie Avatar
    Maggie

    She definitely has an insouciant fuck-you vibe as she sashays away, which makes me feel like she’s not all that heartbroken. But I agree. I have often wondered why she keeps asking. I would think, “Oh, there’s that asshole that hates my hats.” I would NOT be into him when he finally digs my candy-cane party hat.

  73. This is all assuming the dog is female.

  74. So excuse me, but hey, why are so glass half empty about this guy (suspending judgment about the gender of either party here and just letting your narrow one stand because if Im going to make a point I should really stick to just making one point) so like heyt what is your beef with this pleasant chap? What I’m seeing is a dog who is confident in his opinions and who most importantly is honest and always very proper and polite. He is the one who is repeatedly approached by his fashion uncertain friend and asked for an honest opinion.

    He is not cat calling out to her with any crass “Hey lovely thing! I love your hat! Howabout we go back to my place and you you can leave that hat on – if you know what I mean!”

    Nor when approached by this insecure and inexperienced lassie is he abusing his position of power by lying about his passion for any old hat just to get her to come away with him for some sort of inequitable experience.

    You go pleasant honest dog with your frankly somewhat insane opinion of what makes a good hat. Keep on answering politely to any headwear questions you get and keep on wishing your stalkers a “good day”.

    Go dog go

  75. Patrick Avatar
    Patrick

    This is great! I always wondered why this dude would diss her from the very beginning. I think she is at the wrong dog party. I know most straight dogs would immediately like her hat and probably would not even notice her hat or even care about it. Plus, she is the only girl at this dog party! I know many women who were desperate to find Mr. Right and drove into the sunset with a hat loving dog only to find the dog of their dreams humping Clifford the Big Red Dog.

  76. That was fabulous! I read “Go, Dog. Go!” constantly when I was young and studied the crazy, dog party illustration for hours on end! Thank you for providing a whole new perspective on the book.

  77. FckHats Avatar
    FckHats

    This is unfair.
    What if it was just 3 horrible hats and 1 ok hat? Or the other dog is just a bit slow to catch on to the fashion trend? Or the other dog is just not a fan of hats full stop, but finally gets worn down by the hat wearing society and only goes out with her because he’s so insecure that he’s never going to fit in?
    The other dog’s done nothing wrong, he just doesn’t like the hat. Surely he doesn’t have to like the hat? Why are you all calling this dog an asshole?
    If it *was* a male dog that can’t accept that the the other dog is just not into the hat, they’d be instantly ousted as fuck boy or some other creep who can’t take no for an answer and shouldn’t be bothering the other dog so much.

  78. Nicole Avatar
    Nicole

    yes yes yes – can you please now write one for The Giving Tree? ๐Ÿ™‚

    1. Raquel D'Apice Avatar
      Raquel D’Apice

      I feel like I’ve been writing that one in my head since before I even had a kid. ๐Ÿ˜‰

  79. Someone Avatar
    Someone

    This is unfair.
    What if it was just 3 horrible hats and 1 ok hat? Or the other dog is just a bit slow to catch on to the fashion trend? Or the other dog is just not a fan of hats full stop, but finally gets worn down by the hat wearing society and only goes out with her because he’s so insecure that he’s never going to fit in?
    The other dog’s done nothing wrong, he just doesn’t like the hat. Surely he doesn’t have to like the hat? Why are you all calling this dog an asshole?
    If it *was* a male dog that can’t accept that the the other dog is just not into the hat, they’d be instantly ousted as fuck boy or some other creep who can’t take no for an answer and shouldn’t be bothering the other dog so much.

  80. Sati Marie Frost Avatar
    Sati Marie Frost

    I dunno, calling him a “mustard-coloured moron” seems a bit harsh.

    I’d have been more like, “Girl (or boy), the hats are fabulous and you do you. But everyone’s always got the right to say ‘no’ to you for any reason, and frankly you’re starting to get a bit stalky. If it were the same dude coming up to you every day asking if you like his tie, you’d feel a bit creeped out, wouldn’t you? So go enjoy your hats, and with luck you’ll meet someone who’s as into you as you are. Cause being with someone who’s not really into you sucks big-time. Really, it does. Lovely poodle of indeterminate gender, if it’s not ‘fuck yes!’ it’s ‘no’. But don’t worry, there’ll be plenty of ‘fuck yes!’es coming up in life. Don’t settle!”

  81. JoAnn Groh Avatar
    JoAnn Groh

    Go Dog Go

    My son reads Go, Dog, Go with Talmudic care.

    The text,
    which I cradle gingerly
    its spine fragmented
    peeling paint exposing leathery cardboard
    precariously held together by
    two hasty strips of packaging tape,
    Is sacred.

    My son knows pacing is the key
    and delights in the initial simplicity
    โ€œDogโ€
    โ€œRed Dog. Black dog.โ€
    Stating the obvious is ok,
    When you know there is more to come.

    We progress.
    Jacob interrupting each succinct thought as it unfolds.
    โ€œBig Dog. Little Dog. Black and white dogs.โ€

    He monitors for his personal favorites (any dog on a bike) and
    for those whom he must protect.
    Jacob worries about how the dog out of his car
    will fix it without getting hit.
    After all, one accident has already happened, and
    as he likes to remind me,
    the cars are moving fast.

    He becomes agitated by the fact that
    The Blue Dog is in, while the Red Dog is out.
    Not out of the inequity of it all,
    but for the threat implicit in the grumpy bulldogโ€™s demeanor.

    There is no separation between Jakeโ€™s world and the book,
    so he makes me impose a wall-like barrier with my hand.
    Between the bull dog and the dachshund to ensure
    Domestic tranquility, just as he protects the little goldfish that is
    about to be impaled by a dog under water.

    Jake yells at the book.
    He takes command of the Ferris wheel.
    Ordering it to โ€œGo around again.โ€
    He is learning the structures of our society as he
    admonishes the working dogs to
    โ€œWORK!โ€
    And the playing dogs to
    โ€œPLAY!โ€

    He is oddly titillated by the fact that at night a single dog
    stares ahead wide eyed, no sleep in mind,
    While a dog is napping when it is day.
    A rebel is born.

    Jake knows that the Dog going away fast
    will not hit the pedestrian bird –
    as long as the light is red.
    Heโ€™s learned that the world has rules that make us safe.
    After all, can the world really be so bad when
    Dog parties such as these are thrown in trees?

    And that Hat! We try over and over to like that Hat.
    Again and again, until finally the Party Hat arrives.
    The pink poodle knows she has finally nailed it.
    Having endured those humiliating prior efforts,
    Which, while well meant, were unerringly in error.
    Jacob is joyous at this final connection and
    each time we read, he experiences, to the depth of his soul,
    The proverbial riding off into sunset.
    I gently close the book, hug my son.
    And all is right with the world.

    1. Hat-wearing Who Avatar
      Hat-wearing Who

      I changed my mind. THIS is the best book review I’ve seen in ages!

  82. Catherine Kane Avatar
    Catherine Kane

    she asks him if he likes the hat. he says he doesn’t. no problem

    and I’m not sure why you’re bothered by this. It’s not like he seeks her out to crush her spirit. she asks him for his opinion

    and he’s entitled not to like any hat he doesn’t like. saying that the only correct response is for him to say yes, regardless of his opinion(which she asked for) is about crushing His spirit

    it’d seem to me that there are better things to worry about than if a cartoon dog wants to make a point with hats

  83. If she can’t handle his honest answer of whether he likes the hat or not she should not ask – seems to be she’s insecure and fishing for compliments. By him (mustard coloured moron as you eloquently put him) is being honest by answering a question – After the 3rd time of asking if he likes her hat she is not only insecure because she cannot handle honesty she now comes across as needy too – Just what every mustard hat wearing male dog wants – an insecure and needy woman in his life who if life predicts will only be a nagging side piece – so he took advantage of her neediness knowing that a one night shag would be easy and he probably had a few drinks making hher appear less needy in the moment. Women – listen up – you want your men to be honest (always) then don’t ask them the questions unless you are prepared to hear and accept the truth – This dog was remaining in his integrity – any dog who would lie to her and say yes it’s a pretty hat when it wasn’t is bound to lie to her about things that really matter to her too. In the end – mustard coloured male dog lives happily ever after

  84. If you don’t want a truthful answer, don’t ask the question.

    1. Yeah. It’s kind of like asking, “Does this make my butt look big?”

  85. Hat-wearing Who Avatar
    Hat-wearing Who

    Whoever sed that the phrase “mustard-colored moron” was harsh, missed the point of this all too welcome article. The multifaceted point is partly that dating is a numbers game so don’t settle, keep on truckin’; that all of us are subject to a culture of conformity and bigotry but we’re very blind to it; that smallish “parties” are actually just cliques, the world is sooo much bigger than that; and that people’s astonishingly rude self-centered behavior, which is common, even the norm, is out-sized hilarious to caricature. This “letter” is good stuff. Best book review I’ve seen in ages.

  86. Hilarious and on point! I needed to hear this today both for the cheer AND for the self affirming message!

  87. Andria Avatar
    Andria

    This is the most brilliant critique of dog-hat issues I have ever read! Thank you for reminding us to all wear the hats that make US happy.

  88. Melissa Avatar
    Melissa

    I’ve actually always kind of liked that girl dog, because she seems totally unphased by the boy dog’s reaction. She asks, he answers, she seems to go “huh, too bad, I’m on my merry way”. No drama, no hard feelings. Having read this book over the course of 30 years, I’ve always kind of felt like she WAS “you do you”-ing.

  89. Wow! I never got that impression, of the female dog needing acceptance, at all! And, I’ve read that book to children for over 20 years. I just read it aloud with the attitude any female should have when asking “Do you like my hat?”. “No, I do not like your hat.” “Good bye.” “Good bye! (ashat! implied in tone)”.

    It’s all in HOW you read that book and let your own voice do the interpreting for the children you read it to.

    It’s the same with Green Eggs and Ham. That Sam-I-Am! read with all the frustration of a person who’s been bothered beyond belief. Not to mention Marvin K Mooney, Please go NOW!

    It’s all in HOW you read the book.

    1. Yes! The Cat In The Hat is the same way. It can be read as a fun-loving, rascally friend, or as a more sinister presence, “I do NOT want to go. I LIKE it here… mwah ha ha ha!”

  90. Stella Avatar
    Stella

    Absolutely! Subliminal bad self-esteem building. Into the trash can! (Mother of 2, now adult, wonderful girls ). Tiny comments sit deep. Well said.

  91. Thank you, I laughed SO hard after this terrible, awful week. Thank yjou a million times. “.. a moderately well-drawn ketchup-colored poodle ” Snorting loudly here …

  92. ha ha! this is my favourite childhood book and now it will never be the same for me, but you did make me laugh

  93. why are we gendering cartoon dogs

    there is no proof that all those other dogs are men

    there’s not even really proof that the one is a woman

    stop gendering cartoon gods

  94. Love everything about this. The concept is brilliant and you are hilarious yet with a totally valid and relevant point. The comment above about gendering dogs is irrelevant!! Love this post!!!

  95. yeah! Its is great and I laughed a lot! We should have self esteem..and people should never demoralise a person. People are the products of the thoughts of thier subconcious mind.
    And that story…..i read that in my childhood and will definitly read it again to have a good laugh?

  96. I did not know how much I needed this piece, until someone else shared it on wordpress, and on a whim, I clicked the link. Not only did it make me laugh, which after a incredibly long week, I truly needed. But the entire message that you were putting forth sat very deep with me. I’ve never read that book to my son, he’s more into Superheroes and Dinosaurs than dogs, and I haven’t read it myself since I was a little girl. And back then, I never truly saw the underlying message of the hatwearing female dog being desperate for acceptance. And it sits with me, because for an unfortunate amount of my life, I was the hatwearing female dog. I was desperate for acceptance. I didn’t understand that all I needed to do was be me and love it. No little girl, hell no CHILD, NO PERSON, should ever have to feel that way.

  97. This may be the wittiest thing I’ve ever read. Clever concept, clever writing, and an interesting mind you must have to extract a life lesson from a children’s book it had no intention of delivering.

  98. their relationship resembles my very own… too much… to accurately,too soon. thank you so much for the laughter and every other word that made so much sense

  99. This is hilarious. When I read the books to my sons (which I did too often for my own sanity), I always read her “goodbye” with an annoyed, go-to-hell-I’m-better-than-you-anyway intonation that they loved and still repeat. I’m pretty sure my boys think it was supposed to be read that way.

  100. I too read this book to my boys. Now 26,&23. I also put my own inflection & a word or two. Now i find myself reading Thomas. I like that we can make mistakes, sometimes selfish, but in the end always try to make things right. I tell my lil miracle that its the compassion that we must use. Nice interpretation that many moms like myself had.
    Lol

  101. Dana Ainsworth Avatar
    Dana Ainsworth

    People! I think you are all missing the point! I have long loved this aspect of the book because it reflects on a time when two people could like different things- and be open about it- and still be friends! He isn’t BAD for not liking her hat. He simply doesn’t like it. That’s his opinion. He’s entitled to it. He doesn’t pander to her (even if she IS a well-drawn, well-groomed pooch with enough disposable income to amass a comfortable hat wardrobe) and he doesn’t pretend to like something he doesn’t like. He feels completely comfortable expressing his opinion because he knows SHE IS COMPLETELY COMFORTABLE receiving it! She is confident in herself and can handle being different and he is confident in himself and can handle being different. We know we all have that moment when our friend asks us if we like something… and we know without a doubt that we don’t… and we sit there frantically playing it out in our heads… “if I say I don’t like it, will they still like ME?” Or mostly likely we are asking, “will I HURT THEIR FEELINGS? Offend them? Ruin their self-esteem?” We are all grown-ups here. We can like different things. We can say to our friends… “that dress really isn’t my style but you are rocking it with grace and beauty!” I don’t want my friends or my partner to tell me they like something simply because it’s what they think I want to hear. I want them to be okay disagreeing with me and to know that I won’t take it personally. Because… we’re all different. And I think THAT’S the point Eastman is trying to make ๐Ÿ™‚

    1. EXACTLY! I think the author of this is drawing conclusions based on paranoia. I read this as a child and I only thought, ‘Wow, she’s really into fashion and he’s not – but a party hat is super fun!’ I still prefer wacky hats to ‘proper’ hats to this day. Otherwise it seemed to be a really fun/wacky book. I find it interesting (and frustrating) that multiple people can go through the same experiences and come away with completely different conclusions.

  102. Dear Raquel—I loved this perspective on “Go, Dog, Go” and I found that the viewpoint of mother-reading-to-son is the probably the only reason that this slant has never occurred to me due to the fact that I have daughters. This story by Eastman is one of my favorites and I have always loved the honesty and the way that the female had an occasion to build a wardrobe of hats! In addition, the male dogs preference is not unlike many males: let’s party! We know that females are the glue of society but as such, we can easily forget to have fun—this is where the males come in handy! He may not like all of her hats but she still has her collection! DWD

  103. This is very similar to the letter that I wrote to the sneetches without stars on thars. If I were to rewrite that book, they would have had their own damned party and it would be so good that the sneetches with stars on thars would want to come. No need to mix things up (not that I have a problem with that).

  104. Kryton Avatar
    Kryton

    This approach would only encourage young people to believe that no one elses opinion matters and only your opinion is important. This is not the right way to teach young people to work together or to understand that what other people think does carry some weight and should be considered because as a human being I need to interact with others and I wish to learn about their likes and dislikes. Should I live me life by this no, but that lesson isnt the books job its the parents. I see you are trying to be funny but remember we already think that no one matters but ourselves, is this the child you hope to raise?

  105. I absolutely LOVED what you wrote! In fact, I just got a copy of Go Dog Go and I am going to print your letter and put it inside the book. I will wrap it up all nice and pretty and present it to the mustard colored dog along with the final divorce papers. Good bye. GOOD BYE!!!!

    1. Jean Chambard Avatar
      Jean Chambard

      I love love love your idea! Wishing for you much happiness!

  106. You just had me in lol-ing! Great piece – now I think you should also write an entry to Sam-I-Am, peer pressure is not cool, and I am also sure that sulphuric chicken embryos are generally unhealthy and frowned upon…

  107. Sheri L. Avatar
    Sheri L.

    I am not normally a blog reader, in fact I don’t post on other individual’s blogs. But…I haven’t laughed this hard in a LONG time! In fact I was crying and my stomach hurt! I have read this book about a thousand times, if feels. I had 6 kids and each one seemed to love it. I have often thought about that nameless female dog. I think I may have even made some comments to my kids while reading it. Maybe it is because my husband of 20+ years left me and I have been prone to such self-introspection, but this treatise to “female hat wearing dog” is empowering! Thanks for the laugh and empowerment!

  108. I didn’t know how much I needed this until I read it. Thank you for the reminder!

  109. I was always of the opinion that she wasn’t looking for affirmation but was rather trying to decide if this other guy had good taste in hats. He was the “do not green eggs and ham” of hats, who at the end finally releases his sphincter and loosens up a bit. In fact, she’s the hero of the dang book because she wears crazy hats, regardless of what anyone thinks and finally wins this dud over to her side.

  110. Thank you so much! That was brilliant , loved it!!!
    AP

  111. Every young girl should read this blog post. Better yet, everyone should! Why seek approval from someone who doesn’t appreciate you? OR YOUR HATS!?

  112. The writer of this letter has some serious issues. However, her thinking is very similar to the world we live in today when everyone has to be so PC and you couldn’t possibly tell someone they looked bad or different. You just lie to their face, like this writer wants people to do, and then go back and talk about them behind their back. Can’t people have a difference of opinion without someone trying to create a major issue out of it? What’s the point of asking for someone’s opinion if they’re just going to say, “You look great”. If I were this person’s husband or child, I guess I wouldn’t be asking for her opinion anymore.

  113. I actually thought this was just a fancy boy dog, and the other was his friend who simply has no taste in fashion. ๐Ÿ˜‰

  114. Actually – its about accepting both opinions politely. He is entitled not to like her hat. She is entitled not to find that pleasant. But each recognised the other was entitled to their differing opinions, and that the opinions the other held did not make them less. So they politely acknowledged the other, dealt with their reactions – and were on their way – fully expressed, civilised..

  115. It’s even funnier if you read it aloud.

  116. Wonderful essay/satire ๐Ÿ™‚ and fun perspective. Go Dog Go was and is my favorite children’s book. What I carried away from this book as an introverted child was, “No I Do Not.” There was something really powerful about being able to say one’s truth- no, I do not like that. As young woman growing up I saw so many more times where having a decenting opinion was frowned upon. “If you don’t have something nice to say, don’t say anything at all.” As a grown woman and leader I have referenced “Go Dog Go” and encouraged individuals and teams to be honest with opinions, assessments and beliefs. Even so, the other side of the story that you present is so well articulated and true too! Yes, I did like it!

  117. Shivani Avatar
    Shivani

    This was awesome!! Very well written. I would love to get review from such great writers. I am a newbie, started with some 5 posts.
    cookwhatyougot.wordpress.com let me know how you like them! ?

  118. Omg this is hilarious! I have read that book a million times and always thought he was a jerk. LMAO

  119. This was really amazing.
    Judgement is truly everywhere. It defines what we wear, what we do, who we hang out with, practically our entire existence.
    It takes a lot of courage to stand up to it and say that who I am is what you get.
    This was thought provoking. Take care. ๐Ÿ™‚

  120. All these assumptions and conclusions about sexism, and meanwhile, this dog was never even specified as female.

  121. I read this to my husband and we laughed so hard we couldn’t breathe. We have 6, now grown, children and we have read that book perhaps a billion times. I think the funniest part about it is that on several occasions similar thoughts went through my head and I wanted to read aloud, “Do you like my hat?” “No.” “Well, up yours, then.” And she bopped him right on the nose. (You know how your mind wanders when you’re on the 3,549,784th reading.) Thanks for the memories and the laughs.

  122. When I wrote a post ,’the art of being a weirdo’, these were exactly my thoughts. I tip my hat at you. Good one. Cheers!

  123. I shared your post on my blog (As, An Amazing Piece which complements the art of being a weirdo). I hope you do not mind.
    -Liz

  124. An open letter to the dog who doesn’t like hats.

    Run away!

    Run away fast!
    Run away far!
    You are in control
    And you know who you are.

    You’re one hip dog,
    You’re one cool cat.
    You know where to go
    You know where you’re at.

    Whether you’re scootering with Tom,
    Or skiing with Earl,
    You’re life doesn’t need
    This messed up girl.

    Be she anxious, or shallow,
    Or depressed indeed,
    Be she lonely, or angry,
    Or esteem-in-need.

    She could be mad at the world,
    Or angry with dad.
    She could have just broken up
    With some Dalmation named Brad.

    She wants you to like
    Her hair or her hat,
    But you can never make happy
    A dog-girl like that.

    At first she’ll be lovely,
    So kind and so sweet.
    She’ll fetch you a stogie
    And a whiskey that’s neat.

    But soon you will realize,
    It’s only a trap.
    About all of your pals
    She won’t give a crap.

    You’re young and you’re hot,
    A stud of a pup.
    Don’t bring yourself down
    With this girl who’s f’d up.

    So take this advice
    From a dog in his day.
    When you see her coming at you
    Go-Dog-Go the other way.

    Life’s a dog party,
    On top of that tree.
    So get up there and be
    The best dog you can be!

  125. Michelle Bar-Evan Avatar
    Michelle Bar-Evan

    Um, who says it’s female? I agree with most of what you say, but that has nothing to do with gender per se, but the assumptions we make about a person’s appearance based on perceived society norms.

  126. Mobius Prime Avatar
    Mobius Prime

    A lot of assumptions made on a children’s book.

    Maybe they’re brother and sister?
    Maybe they’re just long time friends?
    It seems they have plans to go to a hat party later, she has many hats she want an opinion on.
    Maybe the dog just didn’t like those other hats?
    Maybe he likes her and was teasing her due to shyness?

    poor dog gets beat up all over the internet.

  127. Michele Avatar
    Michele

    Why should the yellow dog be shamed for telling the truth when asked the same question over and over? It would be worse to lie and just tell her what she wanted to hear. If you don’t want to hear the truth then don’t ask the question.

  128. Tony Lovell Avatar
    Tony Lovell

    if you don’t want to find out someone doesn’t like your hat, either get a REALLY GOOD HAT, or don’t ask people (or dogs) what they think. These hats were “meh”.

  129. You have done what I’ve been thinking of for the past 18 years. everytime I read this book, every 10,000th time, I think the same thing. thank you so much! you couldn’t have done it better!

    1. Raquel D'Apice Avatar
      Raquel D’Apice

      thanks!

  130. Let me start by saying wow! Amazing words of knowledge. Despite that this is a children’s book, us adults, both men and women, can learn from this. At times, we tend to find ourselves seeking and wanting to be accepted and liked by others. I believe that we shouldn’t give a single flip of others opinions towards us. If we feel beautiful and comfortable in our own “hats” then let’s shine and rock it out loud. We all need to learn to know our worth.

  131. I always thought the hat-wearing dog had a lot of confidence and self-worth to keep wearing crazy hats when her friend kept saying he didn’t like them, and I assumed that the exchange between them was a kind of private joke. It never seemed to particularly bother her.

    Good excuse to get in on the Open Letter craze, though.

  132. Walter M Avatar
    Walter M

    I love this book from my own childhood and also from reading it to my now adult daughter, and this is the funniest thing I’ve read in decades (only a slight exaggeration). Thank you!

  133. This just made me happy! I love this book too, but isn’t it wonderful that you can teach not only parts of speech but self worth. Bravo!!!

  134. I loved this book as a little girl. Silly now to look back on it all. I was just happy it was the first book I was able to read to my parents. Still a great book.

  135. Thank you for writing this; apt and appropriate. The comment, THE COMMENTS, wish I had time for a gender analysis of all that!

  136. Femaledog Avatar
    Femaledog

    Ummmmm how do you know the hat-wearing-dog is female?

    A dog’s breed and association of that with our idea of masculinity is a bit silly and dated – not all poodles are females, not all boxers are males. How do you know those three mutts in the boat aren’t ladies? Because they don’t have eyelashes? Dated!

    Probably the book was written and illustrated to imply gender in these dogs, but it’s outdated! Why not instead teach your son that any of the dogs could be women, even that bitch who trash talks the hats and steals feathers!

  137. Interesting way of getting inspiration. And frank post about being yourself no matter what others may think ๐Ÿ™‚

  138. Best thing I have read in quite a while … spot-on observations. LOVE IT.

  139. This article is wrong. This is my favorite childhood book so I felt compelled to click and read it, not knowing it would be some fake, feminist driven, but fairly well writen article on how relationships should go. When I was younger my Dad used to read me this book, almost every night after he would read it I would ask why the dog didn’t like any of her hats. His response was always that people are going to live their entire lives trying to impress other people, live to other peoples standards, become what others want them to become, and that I can’t do that, or else I’d be wasting half of my life, just looking for aproval. This was the most important lesson for me in my childhood, and I still use it today. This article is wrong because of the motif behind it. The author of this blog is trying to tell us that FEMALES are always looking for approval from MALES in a relationship, which isn’t wrong, but it’s much bigger than that. The world is so messed up today because people are only influenced by what is around us, not what is in our hearts. So I agree with you author, WEAR THAT HAT IF YOU WANT TO, but then again, she wouldn’t have even worn that hat if she wasn’t trying to impress the guy. I think P.D Eastman was only trying to warn us that theres better things to do than trying to impress people, like walking through mazes, climbing trees, driving cars around town, riding roller coasters, going swimming with friends, chilling in a hammock, going for boat rides, siting in the sun, partying with your friends, playing baseball, going for rides in hot air balloons, (all things inside the book) sleeping!, partying on top of a tree with strangers!!! There’s so many things you could be doing!! JUST GO DOG GO!

    1. Agreed!!!

  140. Linda R Avatar
    Linda R

    Thank you. That was SO funny. One of my favorite books when my kids were young. I, like Kathryn, have thought back many times on ketchup dogs ‘dogged’ ability to keep rolling happily along even WITHOUT approval. But you put a very funny, well written spin on it….riding off in the sunset together when she FINALLY gets his approval…harrumph! I’m going to buy your book for people I know having babies.

  141. It’s a red poodle. You can’t tell what gender it is. Why did you assume it’s a female? Because he/she liked hats? Or was trying to be fashionable? Your very empowering message might’ve made sense IF the dog were a female, but assuming the dog is a female to make your point brings in so many other complexities into what assumptions you had to make to take that as a given. I have a male poodle dog. People always think he’s a girl. Maybe people need to re-examine their views on poodle gender norms and poodle masculinity in particular.

    1. It has eyelashes. Everyone knows it’s impossible for dudes in a children’s book to grow eyelashes.

      1. Jeanne Avatar
        Jeanne

        lol Nowhere does it show the dog with eyelashes either. Gender neutral dog is gender neutral. Even all the hats have historically been worn by both men and women.

  142. justanotherblog Avatar
    justanotherblog

    I love you!! I love your writing!! I’m new in town, would love some tips and suggestions. You probably have a million people asking you this everyday.. But your writing โคโคโค

  143. Aegina Barnes Avatar
    Aegina Barnes

    Brava! Well done. ๐Ÿ™‚

  144. Hilarious!!! Adorable!! I want to be your friend!! I’m a children’s librarian and will never look at that book the same way!

    1. Raquel D'Apice Avatar
      Raquel D’Apice

      Neat! Being a children’s librarian sounds awesome. I am very jealous.

  145. I had a similar, though not identical reaction to this book. It was a beloved book of my own childhood, but when I began reading it to my daughter over and over again, I began to have a similar problem with the one thread that holds the whole book together. As I would tell her, even before she could put together a sentence, “If a boy you like doesn’t treat you nicely, until one time at a wild party when he is suddenly into you, DO NOT leave the party with that boy.” When she got a bit older, I’d ask her if she could tell me why it would be a bad idea to do so, and after thinking for a moment, she said “Because you might end up marrying him, and he would still probably not treat you nicely.” Close enough, daughter of mine, close enough.

    My sister-in-law references the interpretation here: http://www.theuglyvolvo.com/an-open-letter-to-the-female-hat-wearing-dog-from-go-dog-go/

  146. projectrevo Avatar
    projectrevo

    Hahahaha you are awesome, and this is a great lesson lol. The same people who read the original book and yet not like your article are the same people who won’t get the point of the original book anyway, the fools… Loved this, and though it was satire, I still think it was a good lesson on humanity.

  147. Roger Davis Avatar
    Roger Davis

    I enjoyed and appreciated your take on this book. I read this book, often, to my daughters (not always willingly). Just one comment. In your attempt to teach us about the importance of not living our lives to the approval of others, and maybe an underlying thought of not shooting down (judging) others, your comments on which party was better seemed a little hypocritical..that is a little strong, but those dogs in the boat do not need anyone to approve of their choice of a party.

    1. Raquel D'Apice Avatar
      Raquel D’Apice

      I playfully disparage their boat party but believe me when I assure you that the guy I married is basically one of those dogs.

  148. This is really funny! You’re madly creative!

  149. LOVED IT. Thank you!

  150. Malisa Hagan Avatar
    Malisa Hagan

    You need a like button! I’m shy to write comments and loved your story. First laugh of the morning, thanks.

    1. Raquel D'Apice Avatar
      Raquel D’Apice

      thanks. And I constantly think that everything needs a like button since I hate commenting but don’t like leaving things unliked if I liked them!

  151. Dianne Nordeen Avatar
    Dianne Nordeen

    You are brilliant…but I am guessing you know this :โ€ข) Thank you!

  152. Callie Avatar
    Callie

    You’re writing is lovely. I agree with your stance that a person (or dog) should like him or herself and not constantly change to please others. I do think you jumped to one conclusion. I realized this when I was ready this book for probably the 893rd time to my five year old son. What makes you think the hat wearing dog is a girl? Or that it’s the only female dog in the book. They book never references genders or (thankfully) shows genital of the dogs. The breed (poodle) or color(red)of the dog should not make us assume it is female. Obviously there has to be male poodles, many of which are groomed to same standards as female poodles. Otherwise there would not be pure blood poodles.
    Also, the yellow dog could have been female. For all we know these were two female dogs where one was looking for the opinion of one of her friends on a hat to wear to an upcoming dog party. Not much different than two women going shopping.
    I’m not criticising you or your points. I just wanted to share my thoughts about it while reading to my son and remembered your article. In the end the lack of gender in the book actually made me like it even more.

  153. I grew up reading this book and I used to get so mad at that guy! Good to see that somebody feels the same way as I. It is still a very good book.

  154. Awesome article!-had me laughing out loud. Great way to start the day!

  155. I adored that book as a child and as a parent, and I loved what you did with it. That mustard colored dope did have some nerve. I never saw it the right way before.

  156. Alexis Avatar
    Alexis

    This was gold! Enjoyed every bit of this

  157. Laura Avatar
    Laura

    How many times have I read this wondering the same dang thing!?! I’m glad I’m not the only one. It is a good book though.

  158. BryanBryan Avatar
    BryanBryan

    oh man, it’s been a running joke with my wife since we started reading that book to our son — Do you Like my _____?

    Superbly written, you’ve done this topic justice Raquel! Bravo!

  159. Potty training our oldest! Ahh the memories. Well written post.

  160. Jeanne Avatar
    Jeanne

    Entertaining writing and a very good point. My only thing is, what makes you automatically assume it’s a female dog? Or that any dog in the book is particularly male? There are certainly male poodles and rather feminine looking ones since it’s the style of the cut they’re usually groomed with. If it’s the style of the hats that makes you think it’s female, technically all three pictured are historically worn both by men and women. XD At least until you get to the really crazy hat. And true, this is a big issue far more with women, but no one should let another’s opinion spoil what they love. Wear your hats!

  161. LOVE! I teach a women’s studies course to 10th graders where the final project is to unpack the gender assumptions in an item of popular culture. I’m going to teach your essay as an example of how to do this with style. I see that you don’t live too far from Brooklyn–maybe you’d even be willing to visit my class some day. In any case, thank you!

    1. Raquel D'Apice Avatar
      Raquel D’Apice

      Please do and if I’m ever in town I’m happy to come by and probably make an idiot of myself.

  162. Love your mind! My daughter loves to point out how the dog steals the other dog’s feather every time we read this book. I don’t know why but I unconsciously thought they were both male dogs. Not sure if this means I’m oh-so-progressive or the opposite, like, why do I think all the dogs in the book are male?

  163. Alleycat Avatar
    Alleycat

    In response to your question, because alot of women say men are dogs, heehee, which is not true, of course! ?

  164. Connie Avatar
    Connie

    Best laugh I’ve had in a long time! My favorite book EVER. A different take: he, like so many others we all know, simply has no social filter and assumes his honest opinion is what is required.

  165. Angela A Avatar
    Angela A

    This changed the course of my entire day. Literary gold.

  166. Lisa Linton Avatar
    Lisa Linton

    Brilliant!!!!

  167. I think you’re missing a piece of the story. She, like many of us, doesn’t know how to talk to people she’s interested in. In her case, her workaround is that she wears fancy hats and asks people if she likes them. Based on the story, they end up together, so I presume he, like some of us, doesn’t realize that she’s interested, so he just answers truthfully. When she finally does have a hat he likes, they strike up a conversation, and drive off into the sunset.

  168. My twins also love this book. The first time I read it to them I told my husband it gave a terrible message to our daughter about needing a male’s validation to feel good about herself; he told me I was thinking way too hard about the story. Thanks for expressing my concerns much more effectively and humorously than I did! I will be sharing this with him when he gets home from work today while wearing the yoga pants that I LIKE, even if he doesn’t!;)

  169. I’ve just read all the comments to date. Interesting how many interpretations there are! To those few who suggested that people read too much into cartoon characters or children’s books, I say that no matter what the format, stories always say something about us and even influence the behavior of children. To those who didn’t like the spelling of goodbye: I agree, but I think it’s an old-fashioned version. And if anyone wonders why some people (perhaps more men) feel the yellow dog is answering neutrally or politely and others (often women) feel the yellow dog is mean, I recommend the book You Just Don’t Understand, by the linguist Deborah Tannen, on differences in male and female communication. Her book That’s Not What I Meant! also applies in that it talks about different communication styles in different families. Fun!

    1. Raquel D'Apice Avatar
      Raquel D’Apice

      Love Deborah Tannen and read all her stuff in college or right after, I think! “You’re Wearing THAT” hit home particularly hard but all her stuff is great.

  170. Love your take! My boyfriend says it would pair well with Boundin: https://youtu.be/L_-k_1WQ5As

  171. I just wanted to say thank you for adding the “e” to the end of “good-by,” at the conclusion of your article. Arguably the most annoying part of the book!!

    1. Raquel D'Apice Avatar
      Raquel D’Apice

      YES. Drove me a bit crazy.

  172. Can anyone explain why my version of Go Dog, Go doesn’t have this hat-wearing dog in it? Is this another Berenstein/Berenstain situation?

    1. Raquel D'Apice Avatar
      Raquel D’Apice

      do you have a smaller board book of it? Sometimes those are different.

  173. This is literally the best thing I have read in awhile. I almost busted an ear drum trying to hold in my laughter and not wake my sleeping babes. You rock.

  174. I had a poodle (male) when I was a kid, we had him cut much like the poodles in this book. To be honest, I never assumed the hat dog was female. I kind of thought it was a male dog, as that style of hair cut I had associated with my childhood dog. Does it say somewhere what the genders of the dogs are, or are we (including myself) making assumptions? Unless we check, dogs appearance in real life are somewhat gender neutral, we often assume the incorrect gender with a dog upon first glance. I have a large shepherd/lab mix that people constantly assume is a boy dog, but Izzie is a girl dog.

  175. Stephanie Avatar
    Stephanie

    FANTASTIC. WITTY. FUNNY. AND SO EMPOWERING. I’m currently in school to be an elementary ed teacher, and I’ll be sharing your analysis with my class!! Thank you so much for writing it – there is so much children literature that tells girls to look for validation from boys, and you just nailed it. Please post more!

    1. Raquel D'Apice Avatar
      Raquel D’Apice

      I will try to post more! Good luck teaching elementary ed!

  176. I completely get it. And I LOVE this piece. My one small pleasure in the whole conversation in this book is that I always felt like by smiling as she waved goodbye she was saying to herself “i don’t give a rat’s ass what you think of my hat. bless your heart. MF.” But that was just my interpretation. ๐Ÿ˜‰

  177. You know, sometimes a hat wearing poodle is just a hat wearing poodle. Sometimes Bert and Ernie are just Bert and Ernie. Sometimes Peppermint Patty and Marcy are simply Peppermint Patty and Marcy. Why we develop this need to reinterpret 50 year old literary references to make them “work” in a modern world people like Theodore Bikel and Charles Schulz never lived in is beyond me. But I guess some people find entertainment in reinventing classics, instead of creating something original.

  178. Raquel! “An Open Letter to the Female Hat-Wearing Dog From โ€œGo Dog, Goโ€” is simply brilliant! I enjoyed every word! I feel so much better about myself and the world. In this very trying time, your piece was a needed gift. Thanks and blessings to you! Tobie

    1. Raquel D'Apice Avatar
      Raquel D’Apice

      glad it was enjoyed!

  179. I’ve never, ever commented on a blog before, but I enjoyed this piece so much I wanted to make sure to say how both hilarious and poignant it is. I guess you’ve taken my blog-commenting virginity. ๐Ÿ˜‰ Also, I’ve shared it on Facebook. Kudos!

    1. Raquel D'Apice Avatar
      Raquel D’Apice

      thanks! I rarely (if ever?) comment on stuff as well, so it’s very appreciated ๐Ÿ™‚

  180. Elaine DiMasi Avatar
    Elaine DiMasi

    Ahhh I love seeing somebody love my favorite book so well! I’ve bought copies for my friends’ kids I don’t know how many times. It’s so great that we know all the same dogs, even if we don’t always agree about what gender they’re presenting ๐Ÿ˜‰ That poodle must like something about that mustard colored hound, isn’t that interesting?, and if this is our version of Inquiring Minds Want To Know, good on all of us ๐Ÿ™‚

  181. Oh my God, I love you so much for writing this! Yes to self-actualization of all moderately well-drawn ketchup-colored poodles! SubscriBing to your blog right now.

    1. Raquel D'Apice Avatar
      Raquel D’Apice

      Thanks! Will do my best to keep posting ๐Ÿ˜€

  182. Well, obviously, it isn’t about the hat–The elephant in the room is that she wasn’t “in-heat” when she chose the other hats. Biology has got to have something to do with attraction. Her lack of self-respect and desperate attempts for validation were playing into a sort of “cold bitch” demeanor that only nature itself could ease.

  183. Your analysis is dead-on, and fantastic to read. My professor in my elementary ed – child’s lit class also loved it, and made it required reading for her gender studies class. Additionally, she posted it on our class website so everyone in my child lit class can read it too! I’ve come back and re-read it because it so accurate!! Thank you again for writing this!!!

  184. Did you just assume that dog’s gender?

    1. Raquel D'Apice Avatar
      Raquel D’Apice

      made an educated guess based on when the book was written and how men and women were depicted at the time?

  185. George W. Pseudonym Avatar
    George W. Pseudonym

    I think the party on a boat at night looks like a real good time. And I’m sure they would make room for a cute little ketchup poodle. Poodles are water-dogs after all.

  186. Not only did I love the article and laugh my way through it, I did the same when I read the part below it marketing your book! Funny stuff.

  187. Hilarious. I laughed out loud. And thank you for spelling goodbye correctly.

  188. Diana Louise Carter Avatar
    Diana Louise Carter

    I think you failed to notice that the female dog apparently inspired the male dog to wear a new hat every time he sees her, too. So she’s not just basing her identity on his approval, she’s actually very clever in her manipulation of his behavior. Or maybe she just likes praise. I don’t know. Loved, loved, loved this book as a kid.

  189. Danica phelps Avatar
    Danica phelps

    This is so good!!! Made me laugh out loud, in fact, I can’t remember when I last laughed that hard!… been reading this book since I was a kid and now reading it to my son, hoping to read it to grandchildren one day… and now I’ll be reading this essay alongside it to anyone one I read it to. Thank you for posting!

  190. Giselle Avatar
    Giselle

    This is amusing…this was one of my son’s favorite books and not once did he (or we, actually) think this was a female dog.

  191. Lisa Liel Avatar
    Lisa Liel

    I loved this! Not as much as I love the book, but still.

  192. Jeff H Avatar
    Jeff H

    While you’re at it, can you write an open letter to the mob in Ten Apples Up on Top? Why do you not like the apple balancers? What are they doing to hurt you? And attacking them with a mop? Such violence! They need to get a life!

  193. Jennifer Avatar
    Jennifer

    Ok so when I read this book approx 100 times each year to my kindergarten class… I will confess I make sure the girl dog says “good bye” in a way that conveys how annoyed she is at that scoundrel hound! And inevitably after my class chats about how rude he is. Thanks for the funny article! Totally made my night. ๐Ÿ™‚

  194. Funny stuff.

  195. Harlan Avatar
    Harlan

    The author makes a few assumptions here. One is the sex of the character she calls the “Female Hat-Wearing Dog.” We see a poodle with a common poodle-cut, and the author assumes “female”. Likewise, the “male dog” is an assumption based on “his” rejection of the hat. None of the dogs have visible genitalia or secondary sexual characteristics. Maybe this is a male poodle and a disapproving bitch (in the doggie sense of the word).

    For that matter, the author of the article assumes that the hat-wearing dog is repeatedly asking the same “male” dog for approval and being shut down. Yet, as the article states, almost all of the dogs in the book are drawn as identical, so the hat-wearing dog could be asking different dogs each time until he/she/they finds one with similar fashion sense.

    If we’re going to try and subject a 56-year old children’s book to modern adult sensibilities, let’s go all the way with it. Or just enjoy the dog party in the tree.

  196. Open letter to Raquel

    Lots of assumptions here:
    1) these dogs are strangers (if they are good friends it changes the dynamic)
    2) she likes her own hat. (She may not even like her hat and just wants honest confirmation)
    3) she cares a wit about what he thinks. (She doesn’t ever sulk of look dispirited after he says no)
    4) she feels rejected or dejected. (They share a friendly goodbye after each exchange).
    5) she is a girl and he is a boy. (Other than the hat, there is no gender identification. Shame on the author for assuming a dog wearing a bowler is a boy. And a poodle who likes to wear more ornamented hats is a girl.
    It is just as likely that she is sampling hats to find the one she really wants and wears the sample around in different situations asking her good friend for his or her opinion. Then eventually she or he picks the hat that is the most pleasing to her/him.
    Alternatively, she could be exercising her true heartfelt desire as a strong woman to ornament herself with a hat that the boy of her dreams will admire. There is nothing wrong with that if it is her true personal choice.

  197. Patrice Avatar
    Patrice

    Ahhh, so observant, clever and on point. I kinda think this should be on billboards. Thanks for writing this, and for your heart. ๐Ÿ™‚

  198. Patrice Avatar
    Patrice

    Ahhh, a couple of very articulate and also on point comments were made regarding assumptions. I appreciated and enjoyed those almost as much as the credible use of shading and/or assumptions the author’s piece used to illustrate a very heart-felt experience that I found surprisingly relatable, on a youthful, foundational developmental level. โ™ก

  199. This whole thing CRACKED me up. I’ve always been a little obsessed with this part of this book. My students and I discuss how rude the dog is to always tell the hat-wearer that he/she doesn’t like it. I will say, though, that the hat-wearer never seems too upset or rejected.

    I’m dying that some people are saying the hat-wearing dog is not female. Interesting perspective.

  200. Um…what makes you think the red dog is female?

  201. C Gates Avatar
    C Gates

    Wait! Who says “he” is a male? I have always been a bit angry at that rude dog, but since none of them have genitalia drawn, I always assumed they were ALL female dogs. We all know that hat-rejecting dog is certainly a “bitch.”

  202. Tremendous stuff! The exchange between these two dogs has always been a favorite in our family. We play the scene out in a variety of mundane situations (e.g. Do you like the toast? Daughter responds: I do (or don’t) like the toast?). We have standard voices we use for the dogs so everyone’s in on the joke.

  203. J T Nichols Avatar
    J T Nichols

    Nothing wrong with the truthful answer that the other dog doesn’t like the hat. Could be a favor to let the other dog know, like telling someone they’ve got a piece of broccoli stuck in their teeth..

    1. Honest_Abe Avatar
      Honest_Abe

      was thinking the same thing! each time they parted, he said “Good by” (sic) with a smile! maybe they were in a pre-existing relationship and she was trying to find a hat to wear to the big bash, so she kept coming to her bf / husband to ask what he thought? so many husbands are afraid to tell their wives what they really think when their wives ask “how does this look?”; the honesty in their relationship – and her breaking the down the stereotype of women who can’t handle honest criticism from their partners – should be celebrated instead of demonized…

  204. Terry Lee Avatar
    Terry Lee

    My sister sent me a link to this article when it first came out, but my second child hadn’t aged into “Go Dog, Go” yet. Now that he has, I read this book almost daily. I appreciate what I put my poor father through, almost 50 years ago. This book was so beloved by myself and my sisters that we buried a copy with my mother (upon her death, naturally).

    Curiously, not only have I made the assumption that they are male and female dogs, but I also have made her French (she appears to be a French poodle) and him British (due to the fact that he wears a bowler). My son often turns and stares at me as I struggle to imbue each of their interactions with overtones that befit their genders, their nationalities and their relationship to one another.

    Perhaps it’s Stockholm Syndrome, but I have also informed my wife that I am considering a full back tattoo of the dog party in the book. It’s equally as valid as a Molly Hatchet album cover or, or whatever the kids are doing today.

    1. Raquel D'Apice Avatar
      Raquel D’Apice

      I’m pretty in awe of the dog party full back tattoo idea. Best of luck!

    2. Virginia Avatar
      Virginia

      Holy moly! This is hilarious! Dog party tattoo! Yes!

  205. Ashley Williams Avatar
    Ashley Williams

    This is amazing. I’m a mom of 4 and have always been upset by the plight of the female dog in this book. It resonates strongly with, like, every woman I’ve met in my life. Ever. Thank you.

    Also, your writing style is hilarious. Carry on.

  206. The 2nd most frustrating thing to me about this book is the lack of an “e” at the end of goodbye. I cringe a little every time I read it…which, thankfully, as of late is not often. The dogs I am forced to read about lately are those of the Paw Patrol. Interestingly enough, they also have an incredibly disproportionate number of males to females. Hhmmm….

  207. robin helbling Avatar
    robin helbling

    Spot on! Bravo!
    You absolutely nailed this with your intellect and sharp wit.
    I also think the female dog should be allowed to go sleeveless, in spite of what Speaker Paul Ryan says.

  208. So funny!! Spot on.

  209. Superflychica Avatar
    Superflychica

    Why was the poodle always so self-absorbed?
    Why did she never compliment the yellow dog on his hats? He was obviously inspired by the poodle’s hat to start impressing the poodle with his own hats. And possibly jealous on top of the mountain that the poodle outdid him again. I think the poodle was a bit of a show off throughout the book.
    And, if you are really asking the question, “Do I look fat?”- are you asking for honesty or affirmation? Why are we condemning the honest yellow dog again?
    I think the dogs were playful and fun, and happy with each other in the end, accepting of the hats and the open honesty.

  210. Ann Middlebrook Avatar
    Ann Middlebrook

    Thankyou for this enjoyable read. I just love this book and “Are You My Mother?”. I love looking at the expressions on the dogs faces. My 20 year old son could recite “Are you my mother” by heart at the age of 3. Love the tree party. (Lol…. You got me wondering whether the dogs partied a little too hard, maybe had a little too much to drink and by this stage that party hat on pink dog didn’t look too bad to yellow dog. These days we would see the pink dog as a bit of a desperate but she got her dog in the end. Or maybe yellow dog just needed to learn how to chill and have fun). Thanks again.

  211. Absolutely! Loved this book as a kid, and as an adult feminist, this is the perfect set of glasses to view it. Your words are like music.

  212. First, feeling very silly getting deep on Go Dog, Go. And I’m jumping in on the unpopular side of this. First, the idea of, just-do-you-and-who-cares-about-what-the-other-dogs-think? Awesome. With you. That said, don’t get bagging on the boy dog. The girl dog does keep trying over and over to win his approval… over hats. But the boy dog isn’t being mean. Girl dog keeps showing up unprompted asking him if he likes hat after hat. And he tells her the truth. When they meet he is polite and nice. She asks him if he likes her hat and he says no because he doesn’t like it. Should he lie to her? Is that a better message? She asks, “Do you like my hat?” He lies and says, “Yes!” and then she settles down with the dog who tells her what she wants to hear because who cares? Sorry. I feel insane defending a cartoon dog but… he’s being straight forward with her. And actually while it is better to not let others opinions of you matter, we all do. So… hmmm. You know the right rewrite here? The girl dog crossing paths with a different dog each time but wearing the same hat. It should probably be a crazy hat. Each dog throughout says he doesn’t like the same crazy hat. Then at the end, the last dog says, yes, I do like that crazy hat! And that’s THE dog for her. Because we all need to find that other mutt out there who digs the same craziness we dig. And while no one should hang their self worth or happiness on having someone else… come on, we all want to have someone else to wear crazy hats with and for.

  213. Ron Knowling Avatar
    Ron Knowling

    I dunno – I can’t speak to the first and second hat but the skiing hat looks dangerous. What if it got tangled up in her skis or wrapped around a tree? Did Isadora Duncan teach us nothing? The last hat strikes me as a bit insecure. I think hat one and two are nice hats but hats three and four are bad hats.

  214. What I learned from the hat scene after reading it 1000 times 55 years ago was.

    1. Criticism can be made and accepted in a friendly and loving manner.
    2. Every day is a new day
    3. Persistence pays off.
    4. Function is more important than fashion.

  215. Hillary Weinstein Avatar
    Hillary Weinstein

    I love this post. Every time I read “Good night Dinosaurs” to my 2 year old and I get to the page where the author writes, ” Good night, great-clawed dinosaurs. You look so strange,” I think, omg! So mean! YOU look strange!” Can you please do a send up of those books? Thanks. ๐Ÿ™‚

    1. Raquel D'Apice Avatar
      Raquel D’Apice

      i have never read them, but I’ll keep an eye out!

  216. Virginia Avatar
    Virginia

    Absolutely hilarious! Thank you!

  217. Admittedly haven’t read the book in a while, but you perfectly summed up my inner dialogue back in the days when I read, and reread, and reread, that book!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *